Best Cream Eyeshadow for Mature Eyes


What do you think your peers notice the first thing on your face when you walk into a glossy party? Believe us or not, it’s your eyes! Although colors with rich pigment ought to be the main thing when picking an eyeshadow, let’s not forget the texture. It plays an even more significant role!

If you’re looking for a perfect blend of vibrant color, smooth texture and still haven’t tried out cream eyeshadows, you might have been living under the rock! Well, better late than never! Without further ado, keep scrolling down to find our reviews of the best cream eyeshadow for mature eyes that we strongly recommend!

No products found.

If your eyelids stay super oily all the time, generally, in that case, cream eyeshadows would start to wear off within a few hours. But guess who broke the stereotype? This was done by Revlon’s Creme Eyeshadows, which are waterproof! 

They can smoothly last for more than 24 hours, even without backing down on your eyelids, regardless of a primer or powder. This brand offers four different vibrant colors like metallic, satin, pearl, and matte. Taking them off is very easy and sample. You just need a dual-phase makeup remover to wipe it off your eyelid; that will be enough.

What We Liked

  • Long-lasting (8 hours+)
  • Waterproof
  • Smooth texture
  • Simple and easy use

What We Didn't Like

  • Limited light-shade colors
  • Lack of a variety of smoky shade options

Bring a natural glow to your visage with these rich-pigmented translucent cream eyeshadows that don’t bulge, blemish, or crease. Yes, you saw that right. The eyeshadow vividly sparkles on your eyelids after it has dried and stays bright all the way through an entire day. 

The eyeshadows contain herbal elements enriched in vitamin E. Thus, if you have sensitive eyes, there is nothing to worry about. This eyeshadow is highly unlikely to cause any allergic reactions. The best thing about Almay’s eyeshadow cream is how simple it is to use it and clean it off later. They come in 12 distinct shades with rich pigment quality and smooth texture that causes very little fallout.  

What We Liked

  • Certified safe by an ophthalmologist  
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Simple use and easy clean-off
  • Lasts for 24 hours
  • Enriched in Vitamin E

What We Didn't Like

  • The glitters flake off randomly.
  • Too dark shades

Have got dark circles that make your pigmented eyelids look bad? No worries, Bobby Brown Cream Shadow to the rescue! Just swipe a gentle stroke across your eyelids, and that will be enough to last for a maximum of eight hours straight! As easy as that. This comes in various shades, from light colors to dark eye-popping shades to suit all tastes.

Furthermore, you don’t need to use any primer under that. No matter if your skin is too oily or dry, everyone can use it safely with ease. You can effortlessly blend the shade only using your fingers. Because it’s waterproof, you won’t be able to clean it off using water and soap alone. Try any branded eye makeup remover to do you a favor!

What We Liked

  • Lasts long for 8 hours
  • Effortless and simple to use
  • Wide range of shades
  • Smudge-proof
  • Doesn’t crease or fade

What We Didn't Like

  • Does not dry completely
  • Eyelids feel sticky at the beginning.

You won’t believe unless you try it yourself – this eyeshadow is super easy to use. We are already in love with their creme to powder formula. You seriously don’t need a primer underneath, but you still have to move your hands faster since it dries up too quickly. You have this sponge available on the other tip, which complements in a significant way. 

The long-lasting colors do not fade; instead, stay bright for more than 8 hours. Remember, these waterproof eyeshadow pigments won’t dry off entirely but will still find a way through to stick on your eyelids. Don’t worry, even if you wear contact lenses on sensitive eyes, Julep eyeshadows don’t cause any allergic symptoms.

What We Liked

  • Color stays shiny for a long duration
  • Waterproof and crease-proof 
  • Hypoallergenic formula
  • Wide range of shades available
  • Suitable for both – mature and sensitive eyes
  • Full of Vitamins E and C

What We Didn't Like

  • Not suitable for dry skin

A beautiful thing about these stick shadows is that they are life-saviors, especially when you’re too busy with no time for fancy makeup or in a rush to attend a function. These feel very gentle and glide swiftly over your eyelids. The shades are available in rich pigments that generally stick to the surface of your dry/oily eyelid for long periods. 

Even powder shadows don’t last so long. Another primary characteristic is that it’s super easy to blend the color into the skin – no brush needed. You don’t need to use a primer either. The water-resistant shades don’t crease or smudge and are perfectly suitable for both mature and sensitive eyes.

What We Liked

  • Feels almost like a cream shadow
  • Lasts long up to 8 hours  
  • No post-allergic symptoms 
  • Waterproof
  • Saves time and easy to use

What We Didn't Like

  • The tip will easily break if it falls from the hand.


Can you use cream and powder eyeshadow together?

Well, even the best cream eyeshadow for mature eyes has less variety of colors, that’s why you might want to brush powder eyeshadow along with it. But because both have different textures, a blend of cream eyeshadows on top of powder eyeshadow won’t be wise.

What is the best way to apply cream eyeshadow?

Some like to blend it with their fingers. You can also use a synthetic makeup brush or concealer brushes will do the job.

Read- How to Apply Foundation with a Sponge 

How do you keep cream eyeshadows from creasing?

Though primer is not a must, just to be safe than sorry, you can apply a primer underneath the cream eyeshadow layer to prevent creasing.

Final Thoughts 

Whether you prefer a glossy look or a matte touch on your eyelids, with a very bright pigment or merely a lighter shade – the best cream eyeshadows for mature eyes from our recommendation list are sure to steal away your heart! Why not try out one yourself today!



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here